Research and Discussion Forums

"For the ende of this arte is not to lifte up or beare great burdens, but to move swiftelie. And there is no doubt but he vanquisheth which is most nimble, and this nimblenesse is not obtained by handling of great heftes or waightes, but by often moving."

Been a long time since I've posted ...

Dave Nathan wrote:

I'd like to see someone try to stab me while they're stuck in my triangle choke as I control both of their arms. Would they grab their knife and stab me with only the use of their toes? Haha, I hope not!

I have to chime in a little bit here

You can control both of their ...

I dont intend to get sucked into this debate, however this caught my attention.

You state in your editorial, or seem to imply, that the Western civilizations founded the concept of human rights. But, a Persian ruler, Cyrus the Great, appears to have published a manifesto of human rights in 539 ...

I would add:

The Golden Sayings of Epictetus and The Meditations by Marcus Aurelius, if I may.

They are redundant after your list, but serve to drive the point home.

"There is no new philosophy, only re walking Aristotle's ground."

Agreed, however I havnen't read either. I'm reading Vegetius ...

So much heated debate!

Hmmm... read The Histories by Herodotus; the Anabasis by Xenophon, The Conquest of Gaul by Julius Caesar, The Military Revolution by Geoffrey Parker, Carnage and Culture by Voctor Davis Hanson, The Republic by Plato, and Politics by Aristotle in order to get some idea of ...

Well said. It's nice thats there's a general Western Civilization historical editorial now. Also, I like the bluntness and straightforwardness. Its unfortunate that the point needs to be made so blatant and clear, but it is necessary. It's a welcome addition to the page.

I think there should be ...

yes my website is http://www.historical-pankration.com
i have a few articles on the reserach methodology and general outlines of the art.
Gene is right iconographic work is alot different than working from instructional manuals, but luckily with Pankration i have modern NHB sport ...

We all talk about, write about, practice etc. historical European martial arts. However, I have never seen anything on this website dedicated to fighting skills pre Dark Ages. Most everything is on medieval and renaissance weapons and traditions. Perhaps it is because so much information exists from ...

Nobody's mentioned the Codex!

Pick up the Codex Wallerstein. Its page after page of techniques, from ringen to swords and messers and daggers.

WOW I can't even count how many of those I've done its hilarious when you stop and read it. Great thread.

I too would love to hear of some makers of traditional halberds and bows. Unfortunatley they are probably hard to find, and thats probably why nobody's responded yet.

Jake_Norwood wrote:It's a pretty good show, but not very instructive. It ends up being more demonstration than how-to.

Jake

Jake,

Where could I get or view this video?

I have to agree with Mr. Tallebois. I really don't know how we could accuratley verify with any absolute certainty the physical characteristics of people who lived at least 600 years ago. We can really take into account their likey diet, possible physical routine, and the presence of disease in ...

Wow; I skip a day and all this blows up. I cant even make any points now because the moment has been lost. Anyway, you guys might want to start a new thread about this last page; it has obviously moved in large part off of the original post. These types of discussions if you notice crop up here and ...

It's not about what you're fighting with, it's about how you fight with it.

I think that's something we can all agree with in all cases

Anyway, perhaps I am taking this discussion the wrong way. Are we trying to see using two full swords at once as possibly offering advantages over ...